• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
  • Contact Us
  • +44 (0) 7976 626 544
terrafiniti

Terrafiniti

Sustainability Consultancy, Sustainability Consultants, Sustainability

  • Our Services
    • Sustainability Strategy & Management
    • Sustainability Training
    • Sustainability Reporting
    • Sustainability Review & Benchmarking
    • Responsible Communications Services
  • Sustainable Business Strategy
    • Sustainable Business Guidance & Resources
    • Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)
    • Sustainable Transition
  • About Us
    • Customers
      • 3stepIT
      • 8020 Communications
      • Early Years Alliance
      • RNLI
      • YMCA
      • ISP Case Study
        • Food and Packaging Sector
    • Sustainability Professionals Resilience Group
    • Our responsibility
    • Our Experience & Best Practice
  • Insights
    • Articles
    • Greenwashing
    • Sustainability Issues | Sustainability Trends
      • 2020 Sustainability Issues
      • Trends in sustainable business 2019
      • Sustainability Trends in 2018
      • 2017 – What are the big sustainability issues?
  • Sustainability Books
    • Sustainability Innovation
You are here: Home / Blog / Mind the (massive) gender pay gap!

Mind the (massive) gender pay gap!

“Virtue can only flourish among equals.”

Mary Wollstonecraft

All UK companies with more than 250 staff must report their gender pay gap by 4th April 2018. Of the 9,000 UK companies that are required to report their performance only 3,700 had done so on the 25th March, and more than 25% hadn’t even registered.

What needs to be reported? The Government requires figures for gender pay gaps in mean and median hourly pay, the same for bonuses and proportion of male and female employees in each pay quartile.

What are we seeing so far?

With so many companies still to report, the range so far is already huge, from c. 107 to -107% of mean gap in hourly pay. That means that in some organisations women’s hourly rate is 107% lower than men’s – and the opposite at the other end of the scale. So that’s OK then? Not really, the extremes at either end are the same but the distribution is highly unequal.

Gender Pay Gap data

When digging further into the gender pay data an initial analysis of industry types reveals a few notable issues (as of 19/03/2018).

Within the top quartile (that’s to say where women are either not disadvantaged or relatively less disadvantaged) there are a number of public sector bodies. This maybe expected as public funds should be spent with a view on equality. At the other end of the scale in the lowest performing quartile there are a number of banks, other financial services companies and three airlines. Both examples are likely to be explained by a relatively high proportion of highly paid men in the workforce (i.e. bankers or pilots).

High flyers? Finance & Pilots

Assuming these companies are observing the Equal Pay Act (the data cannot directly tell us if they are or not), there appears to be a huge gender pay gap – why are there apparently so many more highly paid men in the workforce? The reasons appear complex and interrelated. Broadly they are thought to include a range of cultural factors:

  • women disproportionately fulfill childcare and caring roles and are more likely to take leave, career breaks or work part-time. This seems to harm career progression and levels of pay.
  • It has been suggested that women are generally less bullish about seeking progression, for example applying for more senior roles only where they have nearly 100% of the requested criteria – whereas men will apply when they have around an 80% match between skills and the stated requirements of the role.
  • There’s a pipeline issue – women are less well represented in technical and science related (STEM) education and training. These areas are generally more highly paid but have poor representation of women. This is often called the “leaky pipe” and we explored this in an article looking at diversity and STEM careers.

What does this mean?

It’s complicated and doesn’t necessarily mean companies are contravening the Equal Pay Act, it’s more likely that lower paid roles are disproportionately occupied by women. It’s also been suggested that part-time working and a range of conscious and unconscious biases play a part.

Why does it matter?

Ethically, it’s not fair. In utilitarian terms research suggests that more diverse, equal and transparent organisations perform better. While it is difficult to assert a clear relationship between diversity and financial/business performance improvement, there nevertheless remains some compelling evidence on why more balanced and diverse organisations are more successful.

  • A two year survey from Bersin by Deloitte found that more advanced and diverse companies had “3 times higher cash flow per employee over a three-year period” than lower performing companies.
  • The McKinsey Report “Why Diversity Matters” highlighted research which suggests: “Companies in the top quartile for racial and ethnic diversity are 35 percent more likely to have financial returns above their respective national industry medians”. And that “Companies in the top quartile for gender diversity are 15 percent more likely to have financial returns above their respective national industry medians”.
  • Catalyst’s 2007 report “The Bottom Line: Corporate Performance and Women’s Representation on Boards” found that businesses with more women board directors demonstrate a range of clear financial benefits in terms of enhanced return on capital, sales and invested capital.

Gender imbalance – not a good look

It’s long been an interesting phenomenon that if you look at the social and employment policies of most leading companies you would clearly see them as pioneers and upholders of the best liberal-humanist values. The challenge is not that the policies don’t indicate a commitment to equity of access and equality of opportunity, support for flexible working and an acceptance that different people bring different, valuable skills. It’s that, if the current data on the pay gap are correct, there is also a yawning chasm between company policies and their actual practice.

There are of course many reasons why different people get different pay, but at a structural level, the data so far show that companies and society as a whole have a long way to travel to deliver equality when it comes to employment, opportunity and reward.

DISCOVER MORE | Sustainability Issues

Global-Risks-2023

WEF Global Risks 2023 – What’s new and what’s changed?

While big picture environmental threats of climate change, nature loss and ecosystem collapse remain long term risks, geopolitical instability and the current cost-of-living crisis challenges present emerging challenges to the chance for global consensus and coordinated action.
The WEF (World …

Sustainable-Business-Challenges 2023

2023 sustainable business trends and challenges – what to watch out for

From avoiding greenwashing to facing soaring business costs, 2023 is set to be a challenging year for most business leaders to navigate.
Regulators, customers and consumers have increasing expectations for good quality, consistent information on sustainability. Communication must be accurate and …

Sustainable-value-creation

Sustainable value creation

Understanding the relationship between your organisation and the wider world, and identifying which issues, trends, dependencies and risks are material (important) to your business future is critical. Not just for measuring and managing impact, but also for developing resilience and responding to …

Small particle air pollution - cars on street, back lit air pollution

Something in the air – the burden of air pollution

Small particle air pollution – when will we clear it? PM2.5 (small particle) air pollution is one of the most harmful types for human health, exposure has been linked to heart and lung disease, mental health and many other conditions including stroke, cancer and mental health. Air pollution …

Greenwashing-what-do-marketeers-need-to-get-right

Greenwashing – as regulators mobilise, what do marketers need to get right?

Greenwashing is insidious and widespread. It’s also harmful to your reputation, one of the main sources of value from taking meaningful action on sustainability issues.
And greenwashing is becoming a tidal wave.
So how should marketers and other professionals tackle this?

Global-risks-2022

Global Risks 2022

Most major sustainability issues have important risk dimensions for companies – and societies. In many cases these are still not adequately represented in board-level discussion, company risk assessments or registers.
WEF’s Global Risk Report provides a very useful, comprehensive global review and …

COP26 What was achieved?

COP 26 – WHAT WAS ACHIEVED?

Overall Glasgow’s COP26 made good progress in some areas but failed to move others forward – what was really achieved? The world is still way off track for the Paris 1.5 degrees C – the widely accepted target that only really represents ‘hopefully not too dangerous’.

Biodiversity-Crisis-Red-Deer-Stag-Richmond-Park

Biodiversity – the next crisis?

While we’ve been concerned with action on climate and tied up with Covid19, a larger, related crisis is brewing. Businesses are waking up to the need for action on biodiversity.
Biodiversity is one of many issues organisations should consider when developing (or reviewing) sustainable business …

Diesel and petrol car ban - retro energy, petrol pump

The Diesel and petrol car ban has been brought forward!

UK Government announces diesel and petrol car ban to be brought forward to 2035 while dispute mires COP 26 announcement in a mixed day of climate news.

Business-Purpose-Sustainability

Sustainability Issues 2020 | Business Purpose

Research shows people are losing trust in public institutions and even capitalism as it is now. What can businesses do to build trust?

Article by: Dominic Tantram Topic: Blog, Provocations, Thoughts and Big Ideas, Sustainability Issues

About Dominic Tantram

View all posts by Dominic Tantram ->

Previous Post:Sustainability of profit - looking onwardsThe sustainability of profit – stop looking back
Next Post:Sustainability Managers: key challenges to best practiceJumping-hurdles sustainability best practice?

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sidebar

Who Are We?

We are sustainability consultants helping companies transform purpose and performance.

Sustainability Services
Sustainability Strategy
Sustainability Training
Sustainability Reporting
Sustainability Benchmarking

FREE Resources

DEVELOP your sustainability approach – with these insight-packed free guides

DEVELOP your sustainability approach – with these insight-packed free guides

Toward 9 billion Sustainability ebooks Towards 9 Billion Sustainability Books | Innovation for a sustainable future Big ideas, provocations and practical guidance at the cutting edge of sustainability Toward 9 billion Sustainability ebooks
“Short, sharp, accessible insights on what the future might look like and how you should prepare for it.”

Mike Barry, Director - Plan A, Marks & Spencer plc

Categories

  • Blog
  • Innovation
  • News
    • Events
  • Practical Guidance
    • Hints and Tips
    • Tools and Solutions
  • Provocations, Thoughts and Big Ideas
    • Natural Capital
    • Provocations
    • Redefining Value
    • Towards 9 Billion
  • Satire
  • Sustainability Issues
  • Sustainability Professionals Resilience Group | SPRG
  • Sustainability Reporting
  • Sustainability Shorts
  • Sustainable Business Management
  • Sustainable Business Strategy
  • Sustainable Economics & Finance
  • Sustainable Products
  • Sustainable Transformation
    • Context & Limits
    • Innovation & Transformation
    • Sustainable Change
    • Sustainable energy
    • Sustainable Value
  • Training and skills

Recent Posts

  • WEF Global Risks 2023 – What’s new and what’s changed?
  • 2023 sustainable business trends and challenges – what to watch out for
  • Greenwashing Copy Creator *
  • Greenwashing 2022 – turning up the heat on green claims
  • ESG and Sustainability Reporting – are you engaging your investors?

Terrafiniti LLP

Guildford Institute, Ward Street, Guildford, Surrey. GU1 4LH. United Kingdom

Telephone: +44 (0) 7976 626 544

Email us

  • Consulting In Sustainability
  • About Us
  • Insights
  • News
  • Privacy Notice
  • Our Services
  • Sustainable Business
  • Customers
  • Sustainability Books

twitter  Follow us on Twitter

Link In with Joss Tantram  Connect with us on LinkedIn

1% for the planet

Copyright © 2023 · Terrafiniti