• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
  • Contact Us
  • +44 (0) 7976 626 544
terrafiniti

Terrafiniti

Sustainability Consultancy, Sustainability Consultants, Sustainability

  • Sustainability Services
    • Sustainability Strategy & Management
      • Double Materiality Assessment (DMA)
    • Sustainability Training
    • Sustainability Reporting
    • Sustainability Review & Benchmarking
    • Responsible Communications Services
  • Sustainable Business Strategy
    • Sustainable Business Guidance & Resources
    • Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)
    • Sustainable Transition
  • About Us
    • Customers
      • 3stepIT
      • 8020 Communications
      • Early Years Alliance
      • RNLI
      • YMCA
      • ISP Case Study
        • Food and Packaging Sector
    • Sustainability Professionals Resilience Group
    • Our responsibility
    • Our Experience & Best Practice
  • Insights
    • Articles
    • Greenwashing
      • The Greenwash Files
      • An Essential Guide to Avoiding Greenwashing
    • Sustainability Issues | Sustainability Trends
      • 2020 Sustainability Issues
      • Trends in sustainable business 2019
      • Sustainability Trends in 2018
      • 2017 – What are the big sustainability issues?
  • Sustainability Books
    • Sustainability Innovation
You are here: Home / Sustainable Business Strategy / Cost or value? Why is sustainability strategically undervalued?

Cost or value? Why is sustainability strategically undervalued?

Many businesses still need the sustainability business case

“Surely there comes a time when counting the cost and paying the price aren’t things to think about any more. All that matters is value – the ultimate value of what one does.”

James Hilton

One way or another, the dissonance between cost and value (in various dimensions) has been a long-running thread throughout my 25 year journey in sustainability. While discussions on the business case for sustainability might have less prominence now than in the past, the implications of failing to understand it remain in many situations.

Cost or value? Why is sustainability strategically undervalued? - Picture of coin stack & euro notes - stylised

Recent conversations with sustainability practitioners and potential clients have highlighted how many organisations still don’t see the value in developing thorough and meaningful approaches to sustainability. This can be highlighted by many of the key challenges faced by sustainability practitioners.

The business case for sustainability is (shockingly) still either not recognised strategically (i.e. it is understood as an additive factor for operational efficiency or marketing/PR but not as a strategic value creation/destruction factor), or in many cases it is little understood at all.

There often remains a challenge in moving from the general case for sustainability and financial outperformance (see our overview of evidence for sustainability as a value driver) and the specific, where it may be less certain and more difficult to identify sustainable value foregone.

Corporate Sustainability: cost centre or value driver?

This all reinforces the contention that sustainability is often perceived as a cost centre rather than a value centre.

Viewing sustainability as a cost centre is damaging and probably a self-reinforcing fallacy. If you only operate in the area this implies your zones of focus and action are more likely to be self-limiting. Your focus will be on compliance and value protection and not on where the real/significant risks, impacts or opportunities may lie.

It is always important for organisations to understand the relationships between the decisions they make at the ‘heart’ of the value chain and the fact that in many (probably the majority of cases), the largest impacts which arise from a product are those which occur up and downstream. For many categories of product, from agricultural commodities to electronics and white goods (especially for example washing machines) it is the ‘use phase’ of products where the largest consumption impacts arise.

This is illustrated in the diagram below (adapted from “To Whose Profit(ii)”), which highights a sort of ‘reverse pareto’ – where 80% of management effort goes to address 20% of impact.

Sustainability Management Effort and Impact

It is perhaps unsurprising that practitioners focus on areas where they may have greater direct control rather than varying degrees of influence, or where they have concern but little control or influence.

However, given the scale and scope of impacts and the pressing need to demonstrate real performance improvement, there is a growing requirement for considering corporate sustainability in the context of collective value chain effort. This is also the likely reason for poor take-up, as it’s complicated and difficult for the simple reason that it can only be delivered through the actions of other parties, not through the company’s own direct control (unless it is vertically integrated).

Of course, it’s also likely that outcomes achieved from focussing corporate sustainability efforts in areas of the value chain outside the direct control of the business, are also those which would yield the greatest opportunities for value creation.

Strategy Services

Effective sustainability strategy helps leaders from businesses and NGOs navigate the complexities of sustainability and identify opportunities.

Read More

How does your organisation view sustainability?

​It’s possible to identify different ​approaches to corporate sustainability by looking at ​the responses made by businesses as follows:

COST-CENTRE RATIONALE

  • ​Focus on compliance, value protection, cost saving
  • Limited investment in staff and initiatives
  • Less likely to be integrated with core strategy
  • More likely to leave value and business opportunities on the table/to competitors
  • Lower likelihood of managing risks
  • Less able to demonstrate value to investors
  • ​Less focus upon opportunity costs arising from business as usual

​VALUE-CENTRE RATIONALE

  • ​​​Broader focus on value and opportunity
  • Using sustainability for value creation, solving customers current and future needs
  • Awareness of sustainability context, drivers and value built into business development and planning
  • Greater investment in staff and initiatives
  • Longer-term approach
  • Increased likelihood of managing risks
  • More able to demonstrate integrated response and value to investors

Strategic alignment – moving from cost to value

A significant reason why sustainability is still seen through a cost lens is that it is rarely strategically aligned. While corporate sustainability remains separate to core businesses process like strategy, brand, marketing, risk planning, governance and HR it will remain siloed as a poorly understood and infrequently realised fringe activity.

How should corporate sustainability fit into core strategy? The answer of course depends upon specific context and circumstances. However, here is a generalised overview of two common types of competitive approach:

1. Companies with competitive advantage based upon cost leadership

Corporate sustainability approaches which increase operational efficiency, reduce operating costs and enable overall cost reductions in providing products or services.

2. Companies with competitive advantage based upon differentiation

Corporate sustainability responses which enable your brand, product or service to be viewed as embodying ethical values, high quality and other broader values.

In practice, your organisation may employ more than one strategic approach in different markets or for different products and services. Nevertheless, ensuring that sustainability efforts are aligned correctly with the wider commercial approach has the double benefit of improving business performance as well aligning with the way that you already do business.

It is important to note that, regardless of the strategy your business uses to compete, actions which reduce costs and improve efficiency are likely to always be valuable!

Viewing sustainability strategically

Until sustainability is strategically integrated and understood in terms of its potential for value creation, it will remain side-lined as a cost. While this situation persists corporate sustainability will not influence financial performance aspects such as cost of capital and equity risk profile, fail to become a positive differentiator and be unlikely to attract progressive investor interest.

DISCOVER MORE | Sustainable Business Strategy

strategic-greenwashing-is-your-strategy-plausible

Avoiding strategic greenwashing – why your business strategy must be plausible

Worldwide regulators are tightening up on strategic greenwashing to protect consumers, business and market integrity. As further examples arise there is more, we can learn about what regulators will tolerate and what they require of companies.

Put simply, any leeway for general feel-good …

Global-Risks-2023

WEF Global Risks 2023 – What’s new and what’s changed?

While big picture environmental threats of climate change, nature loss and ecosystem collapse remain long term risks, geopolitical instability and the current cost-of-living crisis challenges present emerging challenges to the chance for global consensus and coordinated action.
The WEF (World …

Sustainable-Business-Challenges 2023

2023 sustainable business trends and challenges – what to watch out for

From avoiding greenwashing to facing soaring business costs, 2023 is set to be a challenging year for most business leaders to navigate.
Regulators, customers and consumers have increasing expectations for good quality, consistent information on sustainability. Communication must be accurate and …

Global-risks-2022

Global Risks 2022

Most major sustainability issues have important risk dimensions for companies – and societies. In many cases these are still not adequately represented in board-level discussion, company risk assessments or registers.
WEF’s Global Risk Report provides a very useful, comprehensive global review and …

Biodiversity-Crisis-Red-Deer-Stag-Richmond-Park

Biodiversity – the next crisis?

While we’ve been concerned with action on climate and tied up with Covid19, a larger, related crisis is brewing. Businesses are waking up to the need for action on biodiversity.
Biodiversity is one of many issues organisations should consider when developing (or reviewing) sustainable business …

Top-Priorities-BAU

Transforming the business case for sustainability

In a business context it’s often been necessary to justify why sustainability is important with a business case. While it gets less visibility now, it’s still common to see the symptoms of not having a good business case, or one that’s not widely implemented.

Materiality-more-than-a-feeling-Image by-Alicja-Pixabay

Materiality Matters

Materiality is the difference between a weak sustainability approach and one that’s logical, planned and based upon what’s important. What matters most?

Businees-Case-Sustainability-Balancing-the-Books

The business case for sustainability – can we make money?

Many people are driven by purpose, the ethical dimension of sustainable business. But all businesses need to make money, we explore where value can be found in sustainable business.

Article by: Dominic Tantram Topic: Blog, Provocations, Provocations, Thoughts and Big Ideas, Sustainable Business Strategy, Tools and Solutions

About Dominic Tantram

Dominic is a founding partner at Terrafiniti, helping companies cut through complexity & deliver on sustainability goals worldwide.
View all posts by Dominic Tantram ->

Previous Post:Should-companies-be-sustainability-activistsShould companies be sustainability activists?
Next Post:The business case for sustainability – can we make money?Businees-Case-Sustainability-Balancing-the-Books

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sidebar

Who Are We?

We are sustainability consultants helping companies transform purpose and performance.

Sustainability Services
Sustainability Strategy
Sustainability Training
Sustainability Reporting
Sustainability Benchmarking

FREE Resources

DEVELOP your sustainability approach – with these insight-packed free guides

DEVELOP your sustainability approach – with these insight-packed free guides

Toward 9 billion Sustainability ebooks Towards 9 Billion Sustainability Books | Innovation for a sustainable future Big ideas, provocations and practical guidance at the cutting edge of sustainability Toward 9 billion Sustainability ebooks
“Short, sharp, accessible insights on what the future might look like and how you should prepare for it.”

Mike Barry, Director - Plan A, Marks & Spencer plc

Categories

  • Blog
  • Innovation
  • News
    • Events
  • Practical Guidance
    • Hints and Tips
    • Tools and Solutions
  • Provocations, Thoughts and Big Ideas
    • Natural Capital
    • Provocations
    • Redefining Value
    • Towards 9 Billion
  • Responsible Communications
  • Satire
  • Sustainability Issues
  • Sustainability Professionals Resilience Group | SPRG
  • Sustainability Reporting
  • Sustainability Shorts
  • Sustainable Business Management
  • Sustainable Business Strategy
  • Sustainable Economics & Finance
  • Sustainable Products
  • Sustainable Transformation
    • Context & Limits
    • Innovation & Transformation
    • Sustainable Change
    • Sustainable energy
    • Sustainable Value
  • Training and skills

Recent Posts

  • Coffee ads banned for misleading ‘compostable’ claims
  • What is Responsible Communication?
  • What is Sustainability Training – and Why is it Important?
  • Carbon Neutral Communications
  • Reputation risk and sustainability – who do you work with?

Terrafiniti LLP

Guildford Institute, Ward Street, Guildford, Surrey. GU1 4LH. United Kingdom

Telephone: +44 (0) 7976 626 544

Email us

  • Consulting In Sustainability
  • About Us
  • Insights
  • News
  • Privacy Notice
  • Our Services
  • Sustainable Business
  • Customers
  • Sustainability Books

twitter  Follow us on Twitter

Link In with Joss Tantram  Connect with us on LinkedIn

1% for the planet

Consulting Website Design by PIXEL PERFECT

Copyright © 2025 · Terrafiniti