• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
  • Contact Us
  • +44 (0) 7976 626 544
terrafiniti

Terrafiniti

Sustainability Consultancy, Sustainability Consultants, Sustainability

  • Sustainability Services
    • Sustainability Strategy & Management
      • Double Materiality Assessment (DMA)
    • Sustainability Training
    • Sustainability Reporting
    • Sustainability Review & Benchmarking
    • Responsible Communications Services
  • Sustainable Business Strategy
    • Sustainable Business Guidance & Resources
    • Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)
    • Sustainable Transition
  • About Us
    • Customers
      • 3stepIT
      • 8020 Communications
      • Early Years Alliance
      • RNLI
      • YMCA
      • ISP Case Study
        • Food and Packaging Sector
    • Sustainability Professionals Resilience Group
    • Our responsibility
    • Our Experience & Best Practice
  • Insights
    • Articles
    • Greenwashing
      • The Greenwash Files
      • An Essential Guide to Avoiding Greenwashing
    • Sustainability Issues | Sustainability Trends
      • 2020 Sustainability Issues
      • Trends in sustainable business 2019
      • Sustainability Trends in 2018
      • 2017 – What are the big sustainability issues?
  • Sustainability Books
    • Sustainability Innovation
You are here: Home / Provocations, Thoughts and Big Ideas / Valuing Natural Capital

Valuing Natural Capital

And Selling your Mother – The Remix!

“An ecosystem might be likened to a great biological machine, perhaps. If this analogy is pursued, humanity must be seen as part of the machine. No doubt an important part – an engine, a key circuit – but in no case apart from the mechanism, as is often fallaciously assumed.”

 Haviland Tuf (George R. R. Martin)

This post represents a catch up and re-mix of an idea we published just over a year ago on the growing agenda of natural capital and ecosystem valuation – and our recent framing of the idea as a short animated film. Enjoy!

Natural capital makes the world go round

The idea of pricing the value we get from ecosystems, literally pricing the Earth, has been with us for a couple of decades – famously highlighted (though not absolutely originated) by Robert Constanza in 1987 – whose research found that the value of the Earth to humanity was $33 trillion annually.

The area has been gaining significant momentum with the development and rise of the classification of ecosystem services and the emergence of natural capital accounting approaches and payments for ecosystem services. Environmental and ecosystem products have started trading on international markets and high level conferences such as the World Forum on Natural Capital are popping up like mushrooms overnight.

Fundamental dependencies indicate a value hierarchy

Using a comparable metric like money as a way to put things on a level playing field makes sense, but only up to a point. Such an approach would be fine if the things we were comparing were truly comparable. However, the environment is something you can’t do without.

There is a dependency relationship. Put simply, there is no money without human beings capable of inventing and using it. There are no human beings without food, air and water.

If you can’t measure you can’t be bothered…

The logic of ecosystem valuation is motivated by the idea that we need to value and price the contribution that our economy gets from the natural world; once that value is identified, it can be considered and balanced alongside other priorities.

Value implies price, price implies sales, and sales imply markets — if we are not careful we will reduce everything to money and lose sight of the real value we started with.

The idea that: ‘If we can’t measure it we can’t manage it’ pervades much of our current ways of prioritising activity. However, there are many cases when it simply does not either apply or help.

For instance, how do you quantify the love you feel for your children, your parents or partner? You don’t. You know the value without needing to know the quantity. Finding an exact figure is irrelevant, pointless and borderline offensive.

In essence the trouble with pricing the priceless is that it implies fungibility (economic “swap-ability”); by putting a price on your mother, you are essentially saying that you’d be equally happy with a different one that cost the same.

Valuing the invaluable

Breaking down the value of your mother into monetary amounts based on individual benefits she brings to your life will ultimately sorely undervalue her; such is the dilemma presented by the move towards valuing ecosystem services.

August 2014: Some of the contents of this post were adapted for use in a discussion session on Guardian Sustainable Business, focusing upon the rights and wrongs of seeking to value natural capital. My input included a successful attempt to deploy the Selling your Mother metaphor and a failed attempt to link to this animation. The discussion involved such luminaries as Robert Constanza, Prof Lynn Crowe and Tony Juniper.

Article by: Joss Tantram Topic: Natural Capital, Provocations, Thoughts and Big Ideas, Redefining Value, Towards 9 Billion

About Joss Tantram

Joss is a founding partner at Terrafiniti, mixing practical guidance and big, hopeful ideas for a sustainable future.

View all posts by Joss Tantram →

Previous Post:Towards 9 Billion in Bubbles
Next Post:Terrafiniti on Sustainable Brands

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sidebar

Who Are We?

We are sustainability consultants helping companies transform purpose and performance.

Sustainability Services
Sustainability Strategy
Sustainability Training
Sustainability Reporting
Sustainability Benchmarking

FREE Resources

DEVELOP your sustainability approach – with these insight-packed free guides

DEVELOP your sustainability approach – with these insight-packed free guides

Toward 9 billion Sustainability ebooks Towards 9 Billion Sustainability Books | Innovation for a sustainable future Big ideas, provocations and practical guidance at the cutting edge of sustainability Toward 9 billion Sustainability ebooks
“Short, sharp, accessible insights on what the future might look like and how you should prepare for it.”

Mike Barry, Director - Plan A, Marks & Spencer plc

Categories

  • Blog
  • Innovation
  • News
    • Events
  • Practical Guidance
    • Hints and Tips
    • Tools and Solutions
  • Provocations, Thoughts and Big Ideas
    • Natural Capital
    • Provocations
    • Redefining Value
    • Towards 9 Billion
  • Responsible Communications
  • Satire
  • Sustainability Issues
  • Sustainability Professionals Resilience Group | SPRG
  • Sustainability Reporting
  • Sustainability Shorts
  • Sustainable Business Management
  • Sustainable Business Strategy
  • Sustainable Economics & Finance
  • Sustainable Products
  • Sustainable Transformation
    • Context & Limits
    • Innovation & Transformation
    • Sustainable Change
    • Sustainable energy
    • Sustainable Value
  • Training and skills

Recent Posts

  • Coffee ads banned for misleading ‘compostable’ claims
  • What is Responsible Communication?
  • What is Sustainability Training – and Why is it Important?
  • Carbon Neutral Communications
  • Reputation risk and sustainability – who do you work with?

Terrafiniti LLP

Guildford Institute, Ward Street, Guildford, Surrey. GU1 4LH. United Kingdom

Telephone: +44 (0) 7976 626 544

Email us

  • Consulting In Sustainability
  • About Us
  • Insights
  • News
  • Privacy Notice
  • Our Services
  • Sustainable Business
  • Customers
  • Sustainability Books

twitter  Follow us on Twitter

Link In with Joss Tantram  Connect with us on LinkedIn

1% for the planet

Consulting Website Design by PIXEL PERFECT

Copyright © 2025 · Terrafiniti